Hybrid employees are common in the ministry, especially at smaller churches. There are several methods your church can use to combine salary data from multiple reports for a hybrid employee.
Throughout this article, we will use the example of a children/youth/associate pastor at a small church.
Create A Recipe
Before using any of the method’s below, perform these steps for the employee in question:
- Evaluate the employee's job description.
- Identify several similar positions that may match this employee.
- Assign the responsibilities and duties listed in their job description with the similar positions.
- Use this to calculate how much of the job (%) is spent performing each position.
The basic goal is to create a recipe for this hybrid employee—e.g., 18% children's pastor, 25% youth pastor, and 57% associate pastor.
With this recipe in hand, use one the methods below.
Blend salary data from multiple reports using a weighted method.
Adjust the weight of the salary data using the percentages you’ve already established, as if you were measuring ingredients based on a recipe—i.e., 1 tablespoon of associate pastor, a 1/2 tablespoon of youth pastor, and 1 teaspoon of children’s pastor.
The math for a weighted average salary (using normalized data from the chart below) would look something like this:
- (57%) Associate: $62,757 x 0.57 = $35,771
- (25%) Youth: $46,681 x 0.25 = $12,170
- (18%) Children’s: $46,633 x 0.18 = $8,394
- (100%) Total: $35,771 + $12,170 + $8,394 = $56,335
To calculate a salary range, either repeat this weighting process with the first and third quartiles or calculate a new range using your weighted midpoint. Use this free Excel spreadsheet from ChurchSalary to generate a new salary range using a salary spread.
Imagine that you are listing the job online. Which component of the job would dominate your listing? Of the positions you've identified, which does the employee spend the majority of their time doing? Use this to price the job.
For example, does our example church need an associate pastor who can also oversee lay leaders who handle the week-to-week task of teaching kids and youth at the church? Or do they need a children’s/youth pastor who is talented, anointed, and capable of learning how to preach under the tutelage of the senior pastor?
Internal Pay Grades
Every church should develop and utilize a salary structure. Learn more about salary structures and pay grades here.
To use this method, generate a set of reports for the positions you’ve already identified. Look at each set of figures. Determine which internal pay grade at your church best fits the data in your report.
Our example of an associate/youth/children's pastor may not suit this method since associate pastors usually occupy a higher salary grade than youth and children's pastors. Our church would either be forced to choose a tier based on the majority method or to create a hybrid pay grade that suits several other hybrid employees.
Premium & Discount
An advanced method is to assign either a premium or discount based on the market and the job's 'recipe.’ This method is similar to blending; however, it requires a level of intuition and knowledge about the job market that your church may not possess.
For our example, the church may choose to discount their associate pastor role by 10% because they believe that the children’s/youth component will attract younger, less-qualified associate pastors (i.e., $62,757 x 0.90 = $56,481).
Or they may choose to add a 15% premium to youth and children’s salary data because they believe that even though this job fits into the youth/children’s job market, it will require a highly-qualified or talented candidate. ($46,681 x 1.1 = $51,349)